5 Key Things You Should Be Looking at When Comparing Student Loan Lenders

Paying for college with student loans is often frowned upon, due to the stigma of student loan debt being a growing problem in the United States.

However, using student loans to pay for college isn't always a bad thing.  If all the precautions are taken and every avenue is explored, taking out a student loan can be an incredibly financially savvy move. College is an investment after all, and investments don't come free of charge.

Our goal is to make sure you ask the right questions and check the right boxes before you sign on the dotted line of your loan application. That way you'll know exactly what your repayment will look like after college with no surprises 6 months after your diploma is handed to you. 

Let's dive into 5 key things you should know when comparing student loan lenders so you make the right decision for you. But first...

Check out our curated list of student loan offers for you!

What type of loan should you take out?

It seems like it's not as simple as just choosing between lenders. There are also federal and private student loans to think about.

Our rule of thumb is to always take out federal student loans first. These offer the most security and the lowest interest rates, here's why:

  1. Federal loan interest rates are fixed and not variable therefore your monthly payments will always remain the same.
  2. While you're in school, the government pays interest on subsidized federal loans.
  3. Once you graduate, federal loans offer various payment options including income-driven repayment. This means you can pay minimal to keep your finances manageable.
  4. Federal loans also offer student loan forgiveness options for qualifying public service jobs after 10 years.

It's common for federal loans to come up short of what your actual tuition might cost, as these types of loans are determined by you and your family's financial need. Don't fret just yet, that's where private student loans can help.

Shopping around is your ultimate key to success

Now that you have gotten federal student loans to help pay your tuition, it's time to turn to private student loans. Knowing the difference between the two will help you understand why this is your next best option to pay your bill.

With private student loans comes a responsibility that you keep your best financial interest in mind. Always remember that you are your own self-advocate in a big financial process like this.

That's why it's important to not accept just any lenders offer, do your research and follow these 5 steps to get the best deal you can.

Here are our top lenders for 2020:

  1. Discover
  2. Earnest
  3. Sallie Mae
  4. College Ave

1. Know the interest rates inside and out

The biggest difference across private student loan lenders is that they all offer different interest rates, and most give you the option to choose between variable- and fixed-rate loans.

You'll notice that variable-rates tend to be lower than fixed-rate loans. Variable-rate loans can change over time depending on the market. If the interest rates rise, so will your payment and vice-versa.

Fixed-rate loans, like federal loans, remain constant over the life of the loan. The only time the interest rate can ever change is if you refinance your private student loans with a new lender at a lower interest rate

Sallie Mae is a great example, their fixed-interest rate starts at 4.74%, which is much higher than their variable-rate of 1.25%.

It seems like an obvious choice, but keep in mind that a higher interest rate can make a substantial difference in the repayment terms of your loan. Rather than just choosing the lowest rate, look at the whole picture when making this decision to avoid surprises and rates that will extend the life of your loan longer than you anticipate.

2. The secret is in the repayment terms

Term length can make a very large difference in how much your payments are and how much interest you'll pay over time, which is why this should be looked at just as closely as interest rates.

In general, if you have a shorter repayment period, you will have higher monthly payments but pay less interest.

Conversely, if you have a longer repayment period, you will have lower monthly payments but pay more interest.

What you ultimately decide depends on many things, including your anticipated starting salary and any other bills and financial responsibilities you might have.

3. If you choose a cosigner, choose wisely

Most students opt to have a cosigner on their student loan application because they typically don't have good credit or a steady income.

Having a cosigner means you have someone agree that they are responsible if you can't pay your loan. If you miss a payment, this person will be held responsible that the loan is paid.

This is why you should choose someone that you financially trust, but also someone that financially trusts you.

The benefit of having a cosigner is you often can get approved for a lower interest rate depending on their credit score. You also will have more options as many lenders require a cosigner if you don't have good credit or a credit score at all.

At some point, you might want to free the cosigner from your debt and you can do this a couple of ways:

  1. Some loan companies offer a cosigner release that frees the cosigner after you make a targeted amount of on-time payments, proving your are financially responsible.
  2. You can also choose to refinance your student loan into just your name. This can actually get you an even lower rate if you have excellent credit.

Pay attention to what the lender offers for cosigner options if this is important to you and your cosigner.

4. The option to start repayment while you're still in school

Why would you want to repay your student loan while you're still in school?

There are a few reasons why this can be beneficial:

  • You can make pretty small payments that can save you a substantial amount of interest long-term. Think $25 monthly payments.
  • It can build a good habit of paying a monthly payment on time.

However, we understand that paying a monthly payment while in-school isn't always economically feasible for full-time students that are working part-time jobs or not working at all.

Different lenders offer different repayment options while in-school if this is something that interests your financial plans. These options are quite common, so make sure you check with each lender to see if they offer them:

  • Full payments
  • Interest-only payments
  • $25 monthly payments flat (most common)
  • No payments at all

5. Read the fine print in search of loan fees

Origination fees aren't all that common across student loan lenders, neither are prepayment penalties, but it doesn't hurt to double-check.

An origination fee is an initial charge by the lender when you enter the loan agreement as a means of processing the loan.

A prepayment penalty is a fee charged if you pay off the whole loan or part of the loan early, before the intended loan end date.

Overall, let this be a reminder to you to always read the fine print when signing off on any financial decision. There's nothing worse than getting hit with penalties and fees that were clearly outlined in the terms and conditions you didn't take the time to read.

Student loans aren't one size fits all

It's always important to understand your personal financial situation in full before you make a decision as big as taking out thousands of dollars in student loans. Although college is a great investment, if you aren't sure it's worth it, take the time to do all your research and know what you're getting into.

Not all lenders and student loans are created equal, so keeping these 5 key things in mind is going to guide you to make a more informed decision about your investment in college, especially after the fact when you have to pay it off.


College Life Today's top lender picks for 2020

At College Life Today, we strive to offer the best-in-class options for financing your college education. That's why we only feature the best of the best loans for you to compare.

Here are our top lenders for 2020:

  1. Discover
  2. Earnest
  3. Sallie Mae
  4. College Ave
Lender Get started
Fixed APR: 3.49% - 12.99%²
Variable APR: 1.24% - 11.98%²
Apply in as little as 3 minutes and get an instant credit decision
Multiple repayment options from deferred to immediate principal and interest
Choice of how long you take to repay the loan – 5, 8, 10, or 15 years³
0.25% interest rate reduction when you make required payments by automatic debit¹
Borrow up to 100% of your cost of attendance (minimum $1,000)¹

College Ave disclosure
Fixed APR: 4.49% - 12.39%²
Variable APR: 1.24% - 11.37%²
Lowest APRs are available for the most creditworthy applicants for the undergraduate loans and include an interest-only repayment discount and Auto Debit Reward

Discover disclosure
Fixed APR: 4.25% - 11.95%²
Variable APR: 1.25% - 11.40%²
Interest rate discounts available²
Multi-year approval provides a simple way to secure funding for additional years in school

Citizens Bank disclosure
Fixed APR: 5.25% - 9.74%²
Variable APR: 1.70% - 7.68%²
No fees: No application, origination or prepayment fees¹
Social Promise: Your loan helps provide education for those in need

Commonbond disclosure
Fixed APR: 4.13% to 11.37% (with autopay)²
Variable APR: 1.77% to 11.89% (with autopay)²
0.25% interest rate reduction when you make required payments by automatic debit¹
Unemployment protection
4 Repayment options to choose from

Sofi disclosure

Keep up with the latest news